Short-Term Rentals vs. Long-Term Leases: 3 Powerful Factors Every Property Owner Must Consider

When considering renting out your home, deciding between traditional long-term leases and short-term rentals, such as listing it on Airbnb, can be difficult. It’s not just about the money; you have to think about how much work you’re willing to do, the risks you’re willing to take, and what will suit you the best. Another often-neglected tool in making this choice is a traditional property appraisal, something that may help you determine the financial viability of your property for each possibility.

1. Profitability: Tipping Your Income Potential

Short-term rentals are a very strong draw if your house is situated in a thriving community that appeals to tourists or corporate travelers. During high seasons, you can likely command premium prices and notice a significant boost in income. But often, the reality is that the income can fluctuate widely from month to month. A fair appraisal, measuring your home against similar homes in the community, can give you an honest estimation of what you can realistically look forward to, regardless of how attractive those high-season incomes may seem on the surface.

If you’re searching for a stable cash flow, long-term leases are hard to match. When a renter rents for a year (or longer), you can almost guarantee your rent will be arriving each month. In these instances, professional appraisals are apt to focus on prevailing market rents and the terms of lease agreements, so you have an accurate idea of what kind of stable cash flow to expect.

2. Risks: What to Watch Out For

Short-term rentals can be a roller coaster experience sometimes. Sure, you might be bringing in some serious cash during the high season, but there are some downsides. Think about having a couple of slow months, short-term renters who may not be careful about causing damage, leaving you with surprise repair bills, or even dealing with sudden changes in local law.  A careful estimate will account for all these highs and lows and give you a more accurate idea of your real earnings.

While long-term leases provide stability, they are not entirely risk-free. What if, for instance, a tenant defaults on payments or the unit remains vacant between lease periods? Appraisals on long-term rentals will usually consider vacancy rates in the immediate vicinity and previous tenant reliability. Additionally, if a long-term lease has been in place for a while, there may be a gap between your actual rent and the prevailing market rents in your area. This extra intelligence allows you to balance the minor risk with the dependability of assured income.

3. Benefits: The Advantages of Each Strategy

The actual attraction of short-term rentals is flexibility. Not only do you make more money during peak season, but you may even be able to occupy the space yourself when it’s not rented out. An appraisal can help you determine whether the additional money is worth all the additional work involved in handling frequent bookings and turnovers.

Long-term leases are predictable. With tenants remaining for a year or more, a stable monthly cash flow is typically realised, and budgeting is simplified. There is less tenant turnover to cause unexpected disruption. Professional appraisals of these properties typically emphasise their steady performance, which appeals to those who favour a low-maintenance, “set it and forget it” approach.

4. The Role of a Traditional Appraisal

A traditional property valuation offers a comprehensive analysis of a property’s potential in various rental scenarios. For short-term rentals, seasonal demand and local competition are considered. For long-term leases, however, consistent rental income and tenant stability are the focus. This comprehensive analysis provides concrete facts that assist in determining the most appropriate rental strategy based on financial goals and property type.

Final Thoughts

Lastly, the choice between rental options is an issue of market conditions and personal interest. In more active markets where higher returns are possible, short-term rentals can symbolise higher income potential, albeit with a heavier management requirement. Longer-term leases provide stability with less management input. A complete appraisal is a valuable tool because it offers an unbiased opinion on a property’s potential and allows the decision to satisfy financial expectations and lifestyle needs.

You can click here to watch a video. For more information, please click here to contact us.